Wednesday, 27 March 2024

If the Aryan invasion theory is false, then why are the Indian people in the Northern parts fairer than that of the southern parts?

 Note:

1.       Aryan invasion is not accepted by the Academia. It is Aryan migration theory.

2.       Current Indian population was shaped by four major migrations, so everyone is a mix.

3.       The accepted major migrations are : Out of Africa migrations(South Asian hunter gatherers), Proto Dravidian migrations, Austroasiatic migrations (Mundas, Khasis) , Steppe migrations (Aryans)

4.       Aryan migration or the Steppe migration was largely responsible for the introduction of a light skin allele now found throughout the sub-continent.


To understand how Aryans introduced the light skin allele to the Indian sub-continent:

Geneticists propose that as humans started to colonize higher latitudes, where Ultra violet radiation levels were lower, dark skin could not absorb sufficient UVR for efficient vitamin D synthesis, hence natural selection favoured the evolution of light skin.

One of the key pigmentation genes in humans is SLC24A5.

An allele of this gene rs1426654 explains 25–38% of the skin colour variation between Europeans and West Africans.

The ancestral (rs1426654- G) allele of the SNP predominates in African and East Asian populations (93–100%),

Whereas the derived (rs1426654 - A) allele is almost fixed in Europe (98.7–100%)

A recent study showed that the light skin associated allele in South Asians is identical by descent to that found in Europeans. [1]

The study found that rs1426654-A allele is responsible for light skin in Indians.

Frequency of SLC24A5 among global populations:

In short:

Early Humans were all dark.

When humans first moved out of Africa and colonized higher latitudes, they developed light skin.

The Gene responsible for light skin is SLC24A5

A variation of an allele of this gene rs1426654-A is responsible for light skin in Europeans and South Asians.

The ancestral allele rs1426654-G is predominantly found in Africans and East Asians.

The study found that Indo Aryan speakers have the highest percentage of this allele.


The Light skin Allele is high in Northern and North-western regions and virtually absent in NE India :

The study also found that there is a general trend of rs1426654-A allele frequency being higher in the Northern (0.70±0.18) and North-western regions (0.87±0.13), moderate in the Southern (0.55±0.22), and very low or virtually absent in North-eastern populations of the Indian subcontinent

They found that the rs1426654-A allele frequency in South Asia does not significantly correlate with latitude (r = 0.23, p = 0.15).

However, a significant negative correlation with longitude (r = −0.49; p = 0.002) was observed.

The Map shows the distribution of the Allele rs1426654-A :

They found that the Tibeto-Burman and the Austroasiatic language families have the lowest frequencies of the A allele.

The rs1426654-A allele frequency was significantly higher in Indo-European speakers than in other language groups.

In particular, there was a significant difference (p<0.001) between the A allele frequencies of the Indo-European and the Dravidian speaking groups.

They found that both language and geography have a significant influence on rs1426654-A allele frequency, as revealed by Mantel tests (p<0.001).


To make it simple:

Humans who settled in Eurasia evolved to have rs1426654-A allele

When the steppe migrations happened they brought this allele into Indian subcontinent.

Indo Aryan speakers have the highest percentage.

There was significant difference in the percentage of this A allele, between Indo Aryan speakers and Dravidian speakers.

Austroasiatic speakers and Tibeto-Burman speakers have the lowest percentage of this allele.


To have a rough idea of how these early populations might have looked:

The proxy for Indo Aryans: According to

Narasimhan et al

The Modern Indian Cline intersects the Steppe Cline at a position close to the position of the Kalash, the group in northwest South Asia with the highest ANI ancestry proportion.

So, Kalash tribes are a proxy for Indo Aryan populations:

So the first Steppe migrants might have looked like this.

The Proxy for South Asian hunter gatherers are the Irulas:

The SHG populations would have had skin pigmentation close this:

Austroasiatic populations: the Mundas:

Footnotes [1] The Light Skin Allele of SLC24A5 in South Asians and Europeans Shares Identity by Descent

No comments:

Post a Comment