“Why do people say there is no Palestine while Moses bring his tribe to Palestine and Palestine under Roman?”

The statement "there is no Palestine" is a contentious assertion often made in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. However, it is inaccurate to claim that Palestine does not exist historically or geographically. The term "Palestine" has a long history dating back to ancient times and has been used to refer to the geographic region that roughly corresponds to present-day Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip.

Here's some clarification on the historical context:

Ancient History: The region known as Palestine has been inhabited for thousands of years. It was home to various ancient civilizations, including the Canaanites, Philistines, Israelites, and others. The biblical account of Moses leading the Israelites to the promised land encompasses parts of this region.

Roman Period: During the Roman Empire, the region was known as Judea and later as Palestina, derived from the Philistines. After the Roman suppression of Jewish revolts in the first and second centuries CE, the Romans renamed the region Palestina as a punitive measure against the Jewish population, referencing the ancient enemies of the Israelites, the Philistines.

Modern Usage: In modern times, the term "Palestine" has been used to refer to the area inhabited by Palestinians, an Arab population, as well as to the broader historical and geographical region. The modern concept of Palestine emerged during the late Ottoman period and was further solidified under British Mandate rule in the early 20th century.

Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: The assertion that "there is no Palestine" is often used by some parties in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to deny the existence or legitimacy of Palestinian national identity and aspirations for statehood. However, this perspective disregards the historical, cultural, and political realities of the region and the Palestinian people's longstanding connection to the land.

In summary, while the region now known as Palestine has a complex history involving various peoples and civilizations, the assertion that "there is no Palestine" overlooks the historical and contemporary realities of the region and the Palestinian people's identity and aspirations.