Are the claims that India has become the Hindu Saudi Arabia logical?

 The comparison of India to the "Hindu Saudi Arabia" is often a metaphorical expression rather than a literal description of the two countries. This analogy is used in discussions about the increasing influence of Hindu nationalism and the implementation of policies aligned with a particular religious identity in India.

Here are some key points to consider:

1. **Religious Dominance:** The term "Hindu Saudi Arabia" is sometimes employed to highlight concerns about the growing influence of Hinduism in India's socio-political landscape, drawing a parallel with Saudi Arabia's association with Islam. It points to the idea that India, with its Hindu majority, may prioritize Hindu values in a way analogous to how Saudi Arabia emphasizes Islamic principles.

2. **Secular vs. Religious Governance:** India has a secular constitution that aims to treat all religions equally and maintain a separation between religion and state. However, there have been debates and concerns about the extent to which secularism is being upheld in practice, with some expressing worries about the potential marginalization of religious minorities.

3. **Nationalism and Identity:** The rise of Hindu nationalism in India has led to policy shifts and discussions about the cultural and religious identity of the nation. Critics argue that this trend may exclude or marginalize religious minorities, which has prompted comparisons with countries where a dominant religion plays a central role in governance.

4. **Diversity in India:** India is a highly diverse country with various religious, ethnic, and linguistic communities. Any comparison to Saudi Arabia should be made cautiously, considering the diversity within India and the challenges of representing such a complex and varied society.

It's important to note that the term "Hindu Saudi Arabia" is subjective and may be used to highlight concerns or perspectives about the direction of India's governance. Public discourse on these issues can vary widely, with some emphasizing the need for inclusivity and others arguing for the protection and promotion of a specific cultural or religious identity.

In summary, while the term is used in public discourse, it's crucial to approach such comparisons with an understanding of the complex socio-political dynamics in both India and Saudi Arabia and the potential oversimplification inherent in such analogies.